Is Trump right about the U.S. ‘subsidizing’ Canada? | About That

Introduction: Trump’s Claims About Subsidizing Canada

Donald Trump has repeatedly claimed that the U.S. is subsidizing Canada:

“We’re subsidizing Canada to the tune of over $100 billion a year.”

But what does Trump mean exactly? Is the U.S. truly subsidizing Canada, or is this an exaggeration? Let’s explore this claim.


Decoding the $100 Billion Claim

Trump has not provided clear evidence or a breakdown of where the “$100 billion” figure comes from. Instead, he often combines different grievances into a single number.


The U.S.-Canada Trade Deficit: A Closer Look

Trump’s statements appear to hinge on the ongoing trade deficit between the U.S. and Canada. A trade deficit happens when a country imports more from another country than it exports to them.

  • 2023 Trade Data:
    • Canada exported $427 billion worth of goods to the U.S.
    • The U.S. exported $355 billion worth of goods to Canada.
    • This results in a goods trade deficit of $72 billion U.S. (around $100 billion Canadian).

Goods vs. Services: The Full Picture

Focusing solely on goods trade paints an incomplete picture. Services trade also matters:

  • The U.S. has a $32 billion U.S. surplus in services trade with Canada.
  • When combining goods and services, the total trade deficit shrinks to $40 billion U.S. (or $57 billion Canadian).

Is a Trade Deficit a Subsidy?

Trump frames the trade deficit as a form of subsidy, but this is misleading.

  • A trade deficit simply means Americans are buying more from Canada than Canadians buy from Americans.
  • Buying goods (like a jar of mayonnaise) isn’t a subsidy; it’s a transaction.

The Bigger Picture: U.S. Trade Deficits with Other Countries

The U.S. trade deficit with Canada pales in comparison to its deficit with other nations, such as:

  • China: Over $250 billion annually.
  • Canada’s share of the U.S. trade deficit in goods is just 5% and not even in the top five countries with larger trade surpluses.

Trump’s Argument for Domestic Production

Trump suggests the U.S. should produce domestically rather than import from Canada:

“We don’t need their dairy products, lumber, or cars. I’d rather make them in Detroit.”

However, producing everything domestically would likely be more expensive and complex.


Energy Trade: A Key Factor in the Deficit

One major contributor to the trade deficit is crude oil.

  • The U.S. produces more crude oil than any other country but cannot meet its domestic needs.
  • Around 60% of the crude oil the U.S. imports comes from Canada.
  • U.S. refineries are designed for heavy Canadian crude, making Canada a vital energy partner.

The Reality of Energy Trade

Canada’s oil exports support tens of thousands of American jobs in refining and processing. Without Canadian oil, the U.S. would face significant disruptions and expensive retooling of its refineries.


Final Analysis: Subsidy or Trade Relationship?

While Trump argues the U.S. is subsidizing Canada, the reality is more nuanced:

  1. The trade imbalance doesn’t equate to a subsidy.
  2. Canada’s oil exports are critical to U.S. energy needs and create jobs in America.
  3. The trade relationship benefits both countries in complex ways that go beyond the numbers.

I am a hard-working and driven individual who isn't afraid to face a challenge. I'm passionate about my work and I know how to get the job done. I would describe myself as an open and honest person who doesn't believe in misleading other people and tries to be fair in everything I do.

Leave a Comment